As seen on Netflix
Sugar Rush Christmas
A holiday baking competition
Netflix Original Series · 2020
Welcome to the shop.
Creating custom tiers of joy!
A tiny candy-shop bakery on North Fifth Avenue in Beech Grove — hand-painted cakes, decorated sugar cookies, a wall of fifty-five-and-counting candies, and a "do not lick the walls" sign we sincerely mean.
This month
Four tiers, ivory on ivory, sugar peonies set by hand at midnight.
The bride wanted ivory on ivory. The groom wanted raspberry filling. We gave them both — with a single dark fold of buttercream where the thumbprint of the cake-cutter would land.
Dec 2024 · Wedding White × Raspberry Cream · 120 servings
A little of what's been in the case.
Cherries, rainbows, citrus, skulls, princesses, and the occasional groom's-cake barrel of bourbon. Custom is the whole game.
The shop on North Fifth.
Checkerboard floor. Pressed-tin ceiling. A whole wall of fifty-five kinds of candy, sprinkles painted right onto the wall, and a sign above the case that says — we mean it — do not lick the walls.
Some kind words.
Cake show on Netflix, local-TV honor, magazine feature, community badge — we keep good company.
Voted
Indy’s Best Cake
FOX 59 · Indianapolis
Featured in
WeddingDay Magazine
Real Wedding feature
We are a
Business that serves everyone
Indianapolis Chamber pledge
What folks say.
Real quotes from real customers — pulled from Google reviews. 4.9-star average across 70+ reviews.
★★★★★
They did a phenomenal job with our wedding cake. It was true to the reference photo we gave them, with slight creative liberties to make it their own — and it was even more beautiful than the reference.
A bride, after the big day
Google review · 2024
★★★★★
The vision I had for our wedding cake came to life beautifully. Everyone at our wedding ate every bit of that four-tier cake. Raving reviews all night.
Another bride, with no cake left
Google review · 2024
★★★★★
She did my husband's 50th birthday cake and did a phenomenal job. Liz and Mike are so easy to work with — prompt responses, the best customer service, and the best-tasting cakes we have ever had.
A wife who pulled off a birthday surprise
Google review · 2025
A cake is the only edible thing a person remembers for thirty years.— Liz Thompson, baker & owner
Pop in
Stop by on a Saturday morning — the case is always full of something you weren't planning to buy.
Walk-ins welcome for what's in the case. Custom cakes & cookies are by order. Wedding consultations are by appointment — 100 servings or more.